Book Club

Lisa See’s Daughters of the Sun and Moon

This is such a satisfying book. That’s what I thought all the time I was reading Lisa See’s new novel Daughters of the Sun and Moon.

It’s satisfying because it delivers everything the author is known for: complex Chinese female characters, deeply researched Chinese history—and in this book, Los Angeles history—with a plot that spins and whirls with action and drama. Pathos borders on melodrama, redeemed by her dedication to historical accuracy.

The three principal characters are Dove, Petal, and Moon, three Chinese women who arrive in the dusty pueblo of Los Angeles in 1870. The geographical setting is bucolic: vineyards, orchards, and ranches. The pueblo, however, was wild, containing 285 business enterprises including 110 saloons and unnumbered brothels. Yet, there was not one drunk ordinance on the books and none for the sex trade. Chinese labor was essential; Chinese people were reviled.

We are accustomed to thinking of Tombstone and Dodge City as the most lawless towns of that era, but See tells us that in the young state of California, Los Angeles was the most brutal and violent town in Wild West America. Only six officers governed a population of about 6,000, so xenophobic vigilante committees took charge. Lynchings were frequent.

Chinese men worked on the railroads and in the mines. Women were scarce amid a growing anti-Chinese sentiment that wanted to keep the Chinese population from expanding. Into this setting come three women from China. Dove is a classic beauty with bound feet sent by her imperial family to be the second wife of a wealthy merchant. Petal was sold by her peasant family to a brothel, “wife of a hundred men” in the terminology of the day. Moon was the educated wife of a doctor of traditional Chinese medicine. The book is fiction, inspired by real people.

For many readers, their stories are the most important part of the book. The novel traces their day-to-day lives trying to thrive, survive, or escape their situations. We learn much about traditional Chinese medicine—medicinal teas, Chinese licorice for a soothing ointment, Angelica for pain, Astragalus root for burns.

Because I am interested in history, I was enthralled by the account of the Night of Horrors in 1871, a real-life race massacre—perhaps sparked by the abduction of a woman—that mirrors Tulsa’s Race Massacre of 1921. A mob of whites, Mexicans, and Californios (Spanish land-grant families) attacked the old Chinatown sector, killing and looting. The exact number of deaths is unknown, at least 18 or 20. It was one of the largest mass lynchings in American history. A handful of arrests were made, trials were held and verdicts were overturned. In the end, virtually nobody was held accountable. The anti-Chinese sentiment would continue up to and beyond the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882.

For individual readers or book clubs who want to know more about the book, I recommend Lisa See’s website www.LisaSee.com for maps and photographs. Moon, Petal, and Dove each had a favorite tea and these can be found at www.BanaTeaCompany.com.